If you’ve ever debated between water based ink vs plastisol, you’re not alone. Choosing the right ink for your printing project can feel overwhelming, especially when each option offers unique benefits. Water-based ink is praised for its soft, breathable finish and eco-friendliness, while plastisol ink is a go-to for bold colors and long-lasting prints.
But how do you know which ink is the perfect match for your project? Whether you’re printing on t-shirts, bags, or specialty items, the right choice comes down to your fabric, design, and goals. Let’s explore what makes these two inks different and which one might be the better fit for you.
Water based Ink vs Plastisol Ink: Which is Better Ink
What is Water-Based Ink?
It is a type of ink primarily used in screen printing that utilizes water as its main solvent. This ink penetrates the fabric, allowing it to dye the fibers rather than sitting on top of the material. As a result, water-based inks create a softer, more breathable print that feels integrated with the garment itself.
Advantages | Disadvantages |
|
|
Embroidery Digitizing & Vector Art Services
Looking for embroidery digitizing and vector art services that are affordable and reliable? We offer fast turnaround time, guaranteed quality, and the option to preview your design before payment, we make sure you get exactly what you need. Your satisfaction is our top priority, and we’re dedicated to delivering the best results. Don’t wait—try ZDigitizing today and see the difference in quality and service!
Embroidery Digitizing & Vector Art Services
Looking for embroidery digitizing and vector art services that are affordable and reliable? We offer fast turnaround time, guaranteed quality, and the option to preview your design before payment, we make sure you get exactly what you need. Your satisfaction is our top priority, and we’re dedicated to delivering the best results. Don’t wait—try ZDigitizing today and see the difference in quality and service!
What is Plastisol Ink?
It is a widely used type of ink in screen printing, composed primarily of PVC (polyvinyl chloride) particles suspended in a liquid plasticizer. This formulation allows plastisol ink to remain in a liquid state until it is heated, at which point it cures and solidifies, creating a durable and vibrant print on fabric. Plastisol ink is known for its thick consistency and excellent opacity, making it suitable for a variety of textiles, especially darker fabrics.
Advantages | Disadvantages |
|
|
Difference Between Water based Ink vs Plastisol Ink
When it comes to screen printing, plastisol vs water based ink is a common debate among professionals. Both types have unique characteristics that make them suitable for different applications. Here’s a detailed comparison of these two popular inks.
- Composition
- Curing Process
- Hand Feel
- Opacity
- Durability
- Breathability
- Environmental Impact
- Color Vibrancy
- Printing Technique
- Cost and Cleanup
1. Composition
- Water-Based Ink: This type of ink uses water as its primary solvent and contains acrylic resins or hybrid blends. It penetrates the fabric, giving a soft feel and integrating with the garment fibers.
- Plastisol Ink: Made of PVC particles suspended in a plasticizer, plastisol ink forms a thicker layer that sits on the fabric’s surface, offering vibrant and opaque prints.
2. Curing Process
- Water-Based Ink: The curing process involves evaporating the water content at relatively lower temperatures (around 320°F or 160°C). This is a slower process but is gentler on fabrics, reducing the risk of damage.
- Plastisol Ink: This ink cures at higher temperatures (320-330°F or 160-165°C) by solidifying the PVC particles. The process creates a durable and long-lasting print.
3. Hand Feel
- Water-Based Ink: The ink penetrates the fabric, resulting in a soft and flexible print that feels natural and comfortable to wear.
- Plastisol Ink: Since it sits on top of the fabric, plastisol ink creates a thicker and more rigid texture that might feel less comfortable, especially for larger prints.
4. Opacity
- Water-Based Ink: It has lower opacity, making it challenging to achieve vibrant colors on dark fabrics without an underbase. The ink’s transparency can provide a subtle and softer appearance.
- Plastisol Ink: Renowned for its high opacity, plastisol ink can produce bold and vibrant designs on both light and dark fabrics without requiring an underbase.
5. Durability
- Water-Based Ink: While it is reasonably durable, prints may fade or crack over time, particularly with frequent washing or if not cured properly.
- Plastisol Ink: Known for its exceptional durability, plastisol ink can withstand heavy wear and frequent washing without cracking or fading.
6. Breathability
- Water-Based Ink: As it integrates into the fabric, water-based ink allows better airflow, making the garment more breathable and comfortable.
- Plastisol Ink: The thick layer of plastisol ink reduces breathability, which may trap heat and moisture, leading to discomfort.
7. Environmental Impact
- Water-Based Ink: This ink is considered more eco-friendly due to its lower levels of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and absence of harmful PVC or phthalates.
- Plastisol Ink: Containing PVC, plastisol ink raises environmental concerns regarding disposal and toxicity. Proper handling is required to minimize its ecological impact.
8. Color Vibrancy
- Water-Based Ink: Produces softer, more natural tones, often influenced by the color of the fabric beneath.
- Plastisol Ink: Offers bright, vivid, and consistent colors, making it ideal for bold designs that stand out.
9. Printing Technique
- Water-Based Ink: Requires careful handling as it dries quickly in the screen, which can interrupt the printing process. It may also need specific humidity conditions for optimal performance.
- Plastisol Ink: Easier to use as it doesn’t dry in the screen, making it suitable for long printing sessions. This feature makes plastisol a popular choice among beginners.
10. Cost and Cleanup
- Water-Based Ink: Typically has lower material costs and is easy to clean with water, reducing the need for harsh chemicals.
- Plastisol Ink: Although more expensive to clean up due to solvent requirements, it is more forgiving during printing and has a lower learning curve.
Choosing the Right Ink ( Water based Ink vs Plastisol ) for Your Project
Selecting the right ink for your printing project is crucial to achieving the desired results. Factors such as fabric type, print quality, durability, and environmental impact play an essential role in this decision. Below are key considerations to help you choose the best ink.
1. Fabric Type
- Compatibility: Water-based inks are best for natural fibers like cotton as they penetrate the fabric for a soft finish. Plastisol inks are more versatile, working well on blends and synthetics while providing vibrant and opaque prints.
2. Print Quality
- Opacity and Color Vibrancy: Plastisol inks deliver high opacity and vibrant colors, sitting on top of the fabric. Water-based inks offer soft, natural tones but may require an underbase for darker fabrics.
3. Durability
- Wear Resistance: For projects that demand long-lasting results, the plastisol ink vs water based ink debate is significant. Plastisol inks are highly durable, resisting fading and cracking even with frequent washing. Water-based inks, while softer to the touch, may not hold up as well under heavy use.
4. Environmental Impact
- Eco-Friendliness: Water-based inks are eco-friendly, emitting fewer VOCs and containing no harmful PVC or phthalates. Plastisol inks, while durable, have a larger environmental footprint due to their PVC content and cleanup process.
5. Printing Process
- Ease of Use: When comparing water based ink vs plastisol, it’s important to consider the printing process. Water-based inks require careful handling as they can dry in the screen and may need specific humidity levels. Plastisol inks are easier to manage, do not dry in the screen, and are suitable for longer printing sessions.
6. Cost Considerations
- Budget: Water-based inks are cost-effective in terms of materials and easy cleanup with water. Plastisol inks, while slightly more expensive, offer excellent durability and value for high-use projects.
7. Desired Texture
- Hand Feel: When comparing plastisol ink vs water based, the choice often depends on the desired texture. Water-based inks absorb into the fabric, providing a soft and natural texture. Plastisol inks create a thicker layer with a more rigid feel, which may be preferable for bold designs.
8. Specific Project Requirements
- Special Effects: Both water-based and plastisol inks can achieve effects like metallic or glow-in-the-dark designs. Specialized formulations may be required depending on your desired result.
Embroidery Digitizing & Vector Art Services
Looking for embroidery digitizing and vector art services that are affordable and reliable? We offer fast turnaround time, guaranteed quality, and the option to preview your design before payment, we make sure you get exactly what you need. Your satisfaction is our top priority, and we’re dedicated to delivering the best results. Don’t wait—try ZDigitizing today and see the difference in quality and service!
Embroidery Digitizing & Vector Art Services
Looking for embroidery digitizing and vector art services that are affordable and reliable? We offer fast turnaround time, guaranteed quality, and the option to preview your design before payment, we make sure you get exactly what you need. Your satisfaction is our top priority, and we’re dedicated to delivering the best results. Don’t wait—try ZDigitizing today and see the difference in quality and service!
Bottom Line
Choosing between screen printing water based ink vs plastisol ultimately depends on your project’s needs. If you prioritize eco-friendliness and a soft, natural feel, water-based ink might be your choice. On the other hand, if you need vibrant colors and durability, plastisol ink is hard to beat.
No matter which ink you choose, your designs deserve to be perfect. At ZDigitizing, we offer professional vector art services to help you bring your creative ideas to life. With affordable rates, a super-fast turnaround time, and guaranteed quality, we ensure your designs stand out. Plus, we offer a preview option so you can see your design before it’s finalized.
If you’re a first-time customer, enjoy an exclusive 50% discount on your order. Let us help you create something amazing!
FAQs
Water-based ink is a printing ink that uses water as its main solvent, providing a soft hand feel and deep fabric penetration. Plastisol ink is a PVC-based industrial coating used in textile printing, known for its ability to sit on top of the fabric and provide vibrant colors.
The main differences are that water-based ink absorbs into fabric, offering a softer finish, while plastisol ink lays on top of the fabric, creating a more vivid print.
Yes, water-based ink can be used on synthetic fabrics, but it generally requires specific additives or treatments for optimal adhesion and durability.
No, water-based and plastisol inks should not be mixed due to their differing chemical compositions and curing methods, which can lead to printing issues and poor durability.
